Skip to main content
Illustration of a business owner and an IT technician reviewing a cyber insurance questionnaire together

Cyber Insurance Requirements in 2026: What Applications Ask and How to Answer Them

| Pat Midzio |

A client’s insurance broker called with bad news before renewal: expect the cyber insurance premium to go up about 20%. The client sent us the renewal questionnaire, and we went through it together, question by question.

Most answers were solid. A couple weren’t. The application asked about two security controls the business didn’t have in place yet. We put them in before the paperwork went back. The premium came in with no increase.

Not every renewal ends that way, and we can’t promise yours will. But it shows what cyber insurance has become. The questionnaire isn’t a formality anymore. Insurers price your policy, and sometimes decide whether to pay a claim, based on how you answer it.

The short answer: In 2026, cyber insurance applications ask about multi-factor authentication (MFA), endpoint detection and response (EDR), backups, patching, email security, staff training, admin access, and how you verify payment requests. Answer each one accurately for your whole business, not just part of it. Where your setup doesn’t match the question exactly, explain it in writing instead of guessing.

Insurers learned from their own claims. Coalition’s 2026 Cyber Claims Report found that business email compromise and funds transfer fraud made up 58% of the incidents it handled in 2025. Funds transfer fraud claims averaged $141,000. Ransomware was the costliest claim type, averaging $269,000 (Coalition, March 2026).

So the questions follow the losses. Applications that once asked whether you had antivirus now ask how you sign in, how you recover from ransomware, and how your bookkeeper confirms a change to a vendor’s bank details.

Every carrier words its questionnaire differently, but most cover the same ground. Here’s what each question is really asking.

  • Is MFA required for email? Every mailbox, including shared and former employees’ accounts that still exist. “Most people” is not “yes.”
  • Is MFA required for remote access? VPNs, remote desktop tools, and any way into your network or servers from outside.
  • Is MFA required for admin accounts? The accounts that can change settings, create users or turn off security tools.
  • Is remote desktop (RDP) open to the internet? The answer you want is no. Our VPN vs. zero trust guide explains safer options.

If you need a refresher on why MFA matters so much, see why every business should adopt MFA.

  • Do you use endpoint detection and response (EDR)? EDR watches for attacker behavior, not just known viruses. Insurers increasingly ask whether someone monitors it 24/7, not just whether it’s installed.
  • How quickly do you install critical security updates? Many applications ask for a number of days.
  • Do you run any end-of-life systems? Old versions of Windows or servers that no longer get security updates.
  • Are admin rights restricted? Whether everyday users can install software on their own computers.
  • Do you keep backups offline, or protected from changes? Ransomware tries to delete or encrypt backups first.
  • Have you tested a restore? A backup you’ve never restored from is a guess. See how we handle backup and disaster recovery.
  • Do you filter incoming email for phishing and malware?
  • Do you verify payment and banking changes? Typically by calling the requester at a phone number you already have on file, never one from the email.

Our article on the fake invoice link that gave a stranger control of the computer shows how these scams start with a normal-looking email.

  • Do employees get security awareness training? Often with a follow-up question about phishing simulations.
  • Do you have a written incident response plan? Who to call, in what order, when something goes wrong.

In 2022, a manufacturing company called International Control Services signed a cyber insurance application and an MFA attestation. A few months later, it suffered a ransomware attack. During the investigation, the insurer, Travelers, said the company had used MFA to protect its firewall but not its other systems (Insurance Journal, July 2022).

Travelers asked a federal court to rescind the policy. In August 2022, both sides agreed to have the court void the policy from the start, with no coverage for any claims (Insurance Journal, August 2022).

The takeaway isn’t that insurers are looking for excuses. It’s that a “yes” has to be true everywhere the question applies. A partial answer marked as a full one can cost you the whole policy.

Questionnaires are written as yes-or-no questions. Real networks aren’t that tidy.

A common example is MFA. A business can have MFA on email, Microsoft 365 and remote access, but not on its firewall or network switches. Many of those devices don’t support MFA at all. Checking “yes” overstates it. Checking “no” undersells everything else.

That’s why we encourage clients to attach a short addendum to the application. It explains, in plain language, exactly where a control is in place, where it isn’t, and why. Your broker can tell you how their carrier prefers to receive it. Either way, it puts the accurate picture in writing before you need to make a claim.

Start 60 to 90 days before your policy renews. That leaves time to fix gaps instead of just describing them.

  1. Ask your broker for this year’s questionnaire early. Questions change from year to year.
  2. Go through it with whoever runs your IT. Mark each answer as yes, no or “partly.”
  3. Fix what you can before you submit. MFA and admin restrictions are often quick wins.
  4. Write an addendum for anything that’s “partly.” Be specific about what is and isn’t covered.
  5. Keep proof. Screenshots or reports showing MFA, EDR and backup status make any later questions easier to answer.

We can’t tell you how any of this will change your premium. That’s a conversation with your broker. What we can do is make sure your answers are accurate and your setup would hold up if the insurer ever checks.

When a client asks for help with an insurance questionnaire, we walk through it together. We explain what the insurer is looking for, compare it with what the business actually has in place, and help write any addendum.

Many of the controls insurers ask about are already part of our managed IT plans, including EDR/MDR monitored by a 24/7 security operations center, DNS filtering and restricted admin rights. Email security, phishing simulations and Microsoft 365 backup come with our Microsoft 365 & Security bundle. Our cybersecurity page has a table matching common insurer questions to how we cover each one.

Have a renewal coming up, or a questionnaire sitting in your inbox? We’ll go through it with you for free before you send it back. You’ll know which answers are solid, which need a closer look, and what could be fixed before the deadline. Book a time on my calendar, mention your renewal date, or call us at (941) 200-4360.

Pat Midzio

Founder & Chief Technologist, Portolan Networks

Pat has worked in IT since 1998 and founded Portolan Networks in Sarasota in 2020. He writes about the IT and security questions business owners in Southwest Florida ask him most. More about Pat

Common Questions

Most applications ask about MFA on email, remote access and admin accounts, EDR on computers and servers, backups that are protected and tested, timely patching, email filtering, security awareness training, restricted admin rights, an incident response plan, and a process for verifying payment changes. Requirements vary by carrier and policy size.

An inaccurate answer can give the insurer grounds to deny a claim or even void the policy. In Travelers vs. International Control Services, the policy was rescinded after the insurer said MFA was in place on the firewall but not on other systems.

Answer as accurately as you can and attach a short written addendum that explains the details. For example, MFA may be on email and Microsoft 365 but not on network devices that don’t support it. Ask your broker how the carrier wants to receive it.

It can help, but there’s no guarantee. Premiums depend on the carrier, the market and your claims history. In one case, a client facing a 20% increase added two missing controls before renewal and kept the same premium. Your broker is the best person to ask.

Not always. Many policies cover funds transfer fraud or social engineering only through a specific add-on, often with a lower limit. Check your policy and ask your broker.

About 60 to 90 days before your policy renews. That gives you time to get the questionnaire, fix gaps and write any addendum before the deadline.